The Best Spots for a Secret NYC Christmas Marriage Proposal!

There is something truly magical and festive about New York during the holiday season. The Christmas Trees, the sparkling decorations, the store windows, and the energy of this amazing, hustling, and bustling city make it the perfect place for a surprise marriage proposal. Below are some of my favorite spots for your NYC Christmas season proposal.

Here are some of our favorite Christmas proposal locations:

• Brooklyn Bridge Park (Night)

• 6th Ave Christmas Balls & Lights

• Bryant Park Ice Skating Rink

• Gantry Plaza (Night)

• Bryant Park Christmas Shops

• The Plaza Hotel

• Rockefeller Center Christmas Tree

• Lotte New York Palace

Rockefeller Center Christmas Tree

When you think of New York City and Christmas, you instantly think of the world-famous Rockefeller Center Christmas Tree. While this is a magical and festive place, it’s also one of the most densely populated and crowded places in NYC during the holiday season. Don’t believe us on how crowded this area is, then check this! Our team has captured countless picture-perfect secret proposals at the tree before leveraging our experience at Rockefeller Center during the Christmas season.

More Proposals at Rockefeller Christmas Tree | Location Here!

Lotte New York Palace

The Christmas Tree at the Lotte New Palace is timeless, and their courtyard celebration is special. There are carolers, hot chocolate, and decor all around. What’s not present here are the thick crowds, as the Lotte New York Palace is one block away from the chaos of Rockefeller Plaza.

More Proposals at Lotte New York Palace | Location Here!

Bryant Park Christmas Shops

If it’s hard to walk under the Rockefeller Christmas tree, it’s going to be impossible to get down on one knee. Bryant Park features its own Christmas tree and countless holiday shops with festive decorations. The spot we choose in Bryant Park for secret marriage proposals tends to be less crowded than other parts, and would feature the Empire State Building in the background of their proposal.

More Proposals at Bryant Park Christmas Shops | Location Here!

The Plaza Hotel

I don’t think anything is more iconic than New York City’s historic Plaza Hotel during the Christmas season. The staff at the Plaza does an amazing job of decorating the lobby, which is open to the public. For Nick’s proposal, we worked with the hotel to close off an area just to the side of the Christmas trees. What’s nice about a Plaza Hotel proposal is you can tell your partner you have a “reservation” at one of their restaurants or bars. This give

More Proposals at The Plaza Hotel | Location Here!

Brooklyn Bridge Park (Night)

Brooklyn Bridge Park offers a unique view of Lower Manhattan with the Brooklyn Bridge, World Trade Center, and the Empire State Building looking North. This area has several iconic restaurants such as The River Cafe and Celestine, which you can leverage for a reason to be there at a set time; I.e., “I have dinner reservations at 8 pm. Let’s go to DUMBO at 7 pm to check out the view.”

More Proposals at Brooklyn Bridge Park | Location Here!

6th Avenue Christmas Balls & Lights

(Near Radio City Music Hall) - During the holiday season, there is no other place to be than New York City! The city offers so many different places to get that iconic Christmas look and feel: the Rockefeller Christmas tree, Radio City Music Hall, Bryant Park Christmas shops, and Central Park. While the city is very crowded during this time of the year, there are ways to capture big moments like a secret marriage proposal and make it look more intimate than it is. The big Christmas decorations on 6th Ave near Radio City are a great festive alternative to the Rockefeller Christmas tree, and yet close enough to the tree where we can go there for post proposal photos.

More Proposals at 6th Avenue | Location Here!

Bryant Park Ice Skating Rink

Step 1: Coordinate with the Bryant Park Ice Skating Center to obtain permission. During the holidays, the rink is very busy, and a proposal on the ice with the public skating around is strictly prohibited. It would be dangerous, and the rink officials will stop your proposal. Working with the rink officials will provide you with a safe and beautiful moment.

Step 2: Select a time and work with us to photograph the moment.

More Proposals at Bryant Park Ice Skating Rink | Location Here!

Gantry Plaza - Long Island City (Night)

As an experienced professional NYC Proposal Photographer, I know where you should propose and where you should not propose at night. Long Island City’s Gantry Plaza State Park is 110% where you should propose, day or night, as it captures the NYC skyline perfectly.

More Proposals at Gantry Plaza | Location Here!

Jonathan Heisler Photography is comprised of Professional New York City photographers specializing in photographing private NYC proposals, as well as engagement sessions and weddings.

learn more about hiring a proposal photographer

Nick's Plaza Hotel Christmas Proposal

CHRISTMAS PROPOSAL AT THE PLAZA IN NYC

Nothing feels more magical in New York City than The Plaza Hotel in December. The lobby glows with elegant Christmas décor, warm lights reflect off polished floors, and the holiday spirit drifts through every corner. It was the perfect stage for Nick’s surprise proposal just off to the side of the trees—intimate, festive, iconic.

Why The Plaza Hotel at Christmas is a Dream Proposal Setting

• Holiday Glamour & Décor — The Plaza Hotel’s lobby transforms into a winter wonderland each season. The Christmas trees, elegant garlands, and classic architecture combine to create an environment rich with tradition and warmth.

• Luxury + Romance — Telling your partner you have a “reservation” in one of The Plaza’s restaurants or bars adds to the experience. It feels elevated, special, and like a moment out of a storybook.

• Atmosphere of Intimacy Despite the Public Space — Though the lobby is open to guests and visitors, working with hotel staff to close off or designate a side area near the Christmas trees makes for a private, focused moment. Less distraction, more connection.

Capturing Nick’s Moment: Light, Surprise, Emotion

Nick’s plan was thoughtful. He coordinated with The Plaza to ensure a quiet side of the lobby near the Christmas trees could be sectioned off—making space for a surprise, but with the holiday grandeur intact. I arrived early to find the best angles: where the lights would reflect, how the trees framed the space, and where architecture and décor would accent the mood.

When the moment came, Nick led his partner through the lobby under the glow of lights and passed by the grand trees. With soft lighting, ornamental details, and quiet anticipation, he got down on one knee. Her surprise, his joy, the way the lights danced—every aspect carried significance. After she said yes, we used the surrounding decor, details like ornaments and reflections, to continue the story in portraits that feel both cinematic and heartfelt.

Planning Your Plaza Hotel Christmas Proposal

If you’re considering proposing at The Plaza during the holidays, a little planning goes a long way:

• Coordinate with the hotel in advance — Reaching out to staff beforehand ensures you can reserve a quieter corner of the lobby near the trees, so the moment feels private and intimate.

• Time it right — The Plaza’s holiday decorations are seasonal. Planning your proposal during peak décor and in the warm glow of evening lights creates the most romantic atmosphere.

• Choose a festive but tucked-away spot — Near the Christmas trees is perfect. You’ll have the magic of the holiday décor without being overwhelmed by crowds.

• Dress for the occasion — The Plaza has an elegant, timeless style. Outfits with winter textures, rich colors, or holiday tones complement both the décor and the photos.

• Hire a photographer experienced with holiday lighting — Christmas trees, chandeliers, and mixed indoor light can be tricky. An experienced NYC proposal photographer knows how to balance these elements so the photos feel warm, crisp, and cinematic.

The magic of The Plaza at Christmas isn’t just in the decorations—it’s in the way light, tradition, and anticipation come together to amplify the feeling of this moment. If you’re considering a proposal somewhere timeless, festive, and deeply emotional, The Plaza Hotel in December is hard to beat.

Jonathan Heisler Photography is comprised of Professional New York City photographers specializing in photographing private NYC proposals, as well as engagement sessions and weddings.

learn more about hiring a proposal photographer

Photographing Mitchell’s Rockefeller Center Christmas Tree Proposal

When you think of New York City during the holidays, the famous Rockefeller Center Christmas Tree is one of the first images that comes to mind. It’s a place of sparkle, nostalgia, and magic—but also one of the busiest spots in NYC during December. That’s what makes Mitchell’s proposal here even more special: amidst the lights, crowds, and festive energy, he created a moment of surprise, intimacy, and joy.

Mitchell’s Proposal Story:
Mitchell wanted a classic New York holiday moment. He brought his partner to Rockefeller Center, under the illuminated tree, surrounded by the energy of the city at its most festive. As they stopped to take in the scene, he dropped to one knee. The moment had warmth—even with the hustle around them—because the emotions were authentic, heartfelt, and beautifully framed by lights.

Behind the scenes, I positioned myself carefully to catch wide shots of the tree, close-ups of their expressions, and medium shots that include the architecture and glowing decorations throughout the plaza. The contrast between the glowing decorations and the evening sky gave us dramatic color, while reflections in storefront windows added extra depth.

Photography Notes & Creative Choices:

• Light & Timing: We scheduled during the “blue hour” (just after sunset), so the decorative lights were vivid but the sky still held color—perfect balance.

• Crowd Awareness: By arriving early, I was able to scope the scene, anticipate where gaps in the crowd might open up, and select vantage points that framed the couple without too much visual clutter.

• Composition: Shots included the full tree, glimpses of nearby architecture, and close emotional moments. Mirrors and reflective surfaces were used when available to give variations.

• Weather & Wardrobe: Cold winter air meant warm clothing—scarves, coats, and layers. Jackets added to the holiday feel, and their breath in the air added to the atmosphere.

Why Rockefeller Center is a Powerful Choice:

• It’s instantly recognizable: the tree sets a mood that says “holiday in New York City.”

• Multiple layering possibilities: tree lights, street decor, ice rink, storefronts, and ambient city lighting.

• Emotionally charged environment: people are usually already in a festive frame of mind; the backdrop evokes nostalgia, warmth, and joy.

Tips for Proposing at Rockefeller Center During Christmas:

• Visit on weekdays if possible—crowds are lighter early in the evening.

• Aim for dusk or “blue hour” when lights are on but there’s still ambient light.

• Have a backup spot nearby in case the most iconic positions are too crowded or blocked.

• Choose clothing that complements holiday decor (warm tones, festive accessories).

• Work with an experienced photographer who knows how to handle mixed lighting and crowded scenes.

Mitchell’s proposal at Rockefeller Center shows that even in the heart of holiday bustle, you can carve out something truly intimate—and magical. When done right, the lights, décor, and energy of the season only add to the memory.

If you’re planning a holiday proposal in NYC—at Rockefeller Center or anywhere that holds meaning—Jonathan Heisler Photography would be honored to help you craft your moment and capture it beautifully.

Jonathan Heisler Photography is comprised of New York City photographers specializing in photographing private NYC proposals, as well as engagement sessions and weddings.

LEARN MORE ABOUT HIRING A PROPOSAL PHOTOGRAPHER IN NYC

Nick's Rockefeller Center Christmas Tree Proposal

Everyone holds a Christmas memory from childhood—bundled up in the back seat, gazing at twinkling lights against a dark winter sky. For many, that warmth and wonder live on with New York City at Christmas, especially among the decorations along 5th Avenue and the Rockefeller Center tree. On a crisp December morning, Nick brought back that magic—and surprised his partner—under those very lights.

Rockefeller Center during the holidays is grand, festive, and luminous. Every display—ornaments, wreaths, lights—invariably draws crowds, especially at dusk. Because of that, timing is everything. For Nick’s proposal, choosing to go first thing in the morning before brunch meant fewer people, gentler light, and an atmosphere that felt more personal despite the iconic setting.

The Proposal Story:
As the city awoke, Nick led his partner down 5th Avenue, the glow of towering Christmas decorations guiding their path. They stopped in front of the Rockefeller Center tree—its lights still shimmering in the cool morning air. He knelt, and she said yes, with only soft footsteps and distant holiday bustle around them. The moment blended childhood nostalgia, Christmas spirit, and New York City’s grandeur into one unforgettable memory.

Why This Location Works Beautifully:

• It’s iconic — instantly recognized, evoking the joy and nostalgia of NYC in winter.

• Multiple elements in one setting — lights, tree, seasonal decor, architecture all within a short walk.

• Emotional and visual contrast — cold air + warm lights; quiet morning + grandeur of an urban space; natural joy + man-made ornamentation.

Tips for Proposing at Rockefeller Center During the Holidays:

• Plan for early morning or weekdays to avoid heavy crowds.

• Time around sunrise or shortly after for softer light and fewer obstructions.

• Dress in layers—accessories like scarves, hats, coats can enhance both comfort and visual charm.

• Be flexible: have a plan B in case certain spots are too crowded or blocked by holiday crowds.

• Work with a photographer who’s familiar with shooting in mixed & low light settings and can anticipate crowd behavior.

Nick’s Rockefeller Center proposal reminds us that even in the busiest seasons, there’s space for personal moments and glowing memories. The lights, tree, city—when paired with love—become more than just décor; they become part of your story.

If you’re planning your own NYC holiday proposal—whether at Rockefeller Center or a place that feels meaningful—Jonathan Heisler Photography will help you capture it beautifully.

Jonathan Heisler Photography is comprised of Professional New York City photographers specializing in photographing private NYC proposals, as well as engagement sessions and weddings.

LEARN MORE ABOUT HIRING A PROPOSAL PHOTOGRAPHER IN NYC

Austin’s Secret Rockefeller Center Christmas Proposal

Monday night was one of my favorite proposals yet! Austin and Sam had just flown into New York to spend the holiday season sightseeing around NYC. Austin planned some of the trip, but he let most of it be a surprise for Sam. All Austin knew was that Sam had specifically requested to see the Rockefeller Center Christmas tree. So, to kick off their trip in perfect holiday style, he had something even more memorable in store.

The Proposal Story:
Under the glow of countless holiday lights, with the giant pine rising overhead and crowds milling by, Austin led Sam toward the Rockefeller Center tree. It was Sam’s wish to see the tree, and Austin turned that wish into a beautiful surprise: when they reached the heart of the decorations, he dropped to one knee. In that moment, everything felt magical—the tree’s twinkle, the crisp night air, and the glow of the festive atmosphere all around them.

Why This Moment Stands Out:
There’s something extra special about holiday proposals in New York. They combine nostalgia, excitement, and beauty in one frame. You have the Christmas decorations, the energy of people enjoying the season, and the unmistakable charm of the city decked out in lights. For Austin and Sam, this moment wasn’t just about asking; it was about creating a memory from the beginning of their trip—something that sets the tone for everything that follows.

Tips for Crafting a Secret Holiday Proposal in NYC:

• Lean into what your partner loves—Austin knew Sam wanted to see the Rockefeller tree, and built the surprise around that.

• Use public moments to your advantage—the city decorations already set the stage, so you don’t need elaborate setups.

• Arrive early or choose a time when holiday decor is lit but crowds are lighter.

• Capture the raw emotion: the surprise, the joy, the reaction—these are the moments that turn good photos into unforgettable ones.

There’s something enchanting about a secret proposal beneath NYC’s holiday lights. The sparkle, the ambiance, the feeling of something magical unfolding—it stays with you. If you’re planning a proposal in New York City—around the holidays or any time—Jonathan Heisler Photography is here to help you capture every surprise, every smile, and every moment your heart wants to remember.

Jonathan Heisler Photography is comprised of Professional New York City photographers specializing in photographing private NYC proposals, as well as engagement sessions and weddings.

LEARN MORE ABOUT HIRING A PROPOSAL PHOTOGRAPHER IN NYC

Parker's Christmas Proposal in Bryant Park NYC

Parker and I talked about finding the perfect spot for his proposal. We talked about the Rockefeller Christmas Tree, but I knew it would be way too chaotic and busy just two weeks before Christmas. If it’s hard just to walk at the Rockefeller Christmas tree, it’s going to be impossible to get down on one knee. Bryant Park features its own Christmas tree and countless holiday shops with festive decorations. The spot we chose in Bryant Park tends to be less crowded than other parts, and would feature the Empire State Building in the background of their proposal.

How Parker Proposed To Hannah

The Proposal Plan - On their trip to NYC, Hannah and Parker would checkout the Bryant Park Christmas popup shops. After touring the shops and watching the ice skaters Parker would propose.

Proposing in Bryant Park during the holidays

Bryant Park is very busy during the holiday season with both the ice skating rink attracting tourists and the numerous holiday shops. However, there are still some great vantage points for your proposal moment and for photographing beautiful posed photos. If you don’t mind having others around you for your big moment, then let’s photograph your moment in Bryant Park. My experience as a professional New York City Proposal Photographer has given me the confidence and skillset to capture your big moment.

Jonathan Heisler Photography is comprised of New York City photographers specializing in photographing private NYC proposals, as well as engagement sessions and weddings.

learn more about hiring a proposal photographer