Monday night was one of my favorite proposals yet! Austin and Sam had just flown into New York to spend the holiday season sightseeing around NYC. Austin planned some of the trip, but he let most of it be a surprise for Sam. All Austin knew was that Sam had specifically requested to see the Rockefeller Center Christmas tree. So, to kick off their trip in perfect holiday style, he had something even more memorable in store.
The Proposal Story:
Under the glow of countless holiday lights, with the giant pine rising overhead and crowds milling by, Austin led Sam toward the Rockefeller Center tree. It was Sam’s wish to see the tree, and Austin turned that wish into a beautiful surprise: when they reached the heart of the decorations, he dropped to one knee. In that moment, everything felt magical—the tree’s twinkle, the crisp night air, and the glow of the festive atmosphere all around them.
Why This Moment Stands Out:
There’s something extra special about holiday proposals in New York. They combine nostalgia, excitement, and beauty in one frame. You have the Christmas decorations, the energy of people enjoying the season, and the unmistakable charm of the city decked out in lights. For Austin and Sam, this moment wasn’t just about asking; it was about creating a memory from the beginning of their trip—something that sets the tone for everything that follows.
Tips for Crafting a Secret Holiday Proposal in NYC:
Lean into what your partner loves—Austin knew Sam wanted to see the Rockefeller tree, and built the surprise around that.
Use public moments to your advantage—the city decorations already set the stage, so you don’t need elaborate setups.
Arrive early or choose a time when holiday decor is lit but crowds are lighter.
Capture the raw emotion: the surprise, the joy, the reaction—these are the moments that turn good photos into unforgettable ones.
There’s something enchanting about a secret proposal beneath NYC’s holiday lights. The sparkle, the ambiance, the feeling of something magical unfolding—it stays with you. If you’re planning a proposal in New York City—around the holidays or any time—Jonathan Heisler Photography is here to help you capture every surprise, every smile, and every moment your heart wants to remember.
Jonathan Heisler Photography is comprised of Professional New York City photographers specializing in photographing private NYC proposals, as well as engagement sessions and weddings.